The Cylinder Challenge

Three days, three exercises, better cylinders. A self-paced pottery wheel challenge for beginners and improvers. Whether you've been throwing for one month or one year, these exercises can change how you work.

Get the printable challenge (free PDF with a progress log) →

How the challenge works

Each day has one exercise and three balls of clay. You'll throw, cut each cylinder in half, and compare. Cutting your pots open is the fastest way to see what's really happening: where the clay is thick, where it's thin, and how much is left in the bottom.

Ground rules

  • Do one day at a time, or all three in one session.
  • Repeat any day as often as you like.
  • Focus on practice, not output. These pots are meant to be cut up and recycled.

What you need

  • Nine 1-pound balls of clay for Days 1 and 2
  • About 9 more pounds for Day 3
  • Plastic to keep clay covered
  • A timer (your phone works)
  • Wire cutter, needle tool, sponge, water
  • Your phone camera

New to the wheel? Start with Getting Started on the Wheel.

Day 1: Timing is everything

Refresher: the four steps →

Goal: throw a basic cylinder faster, so the clay doesn't soak up too much water and collapse.

Many people take too long to throw a basic cylinder. The longer the clay spins under wet hands, the softer it gets. Shorten the time it takes to form the cylinder and you'll have more time left for shaping and finishing.

  1. Wedge three 1-pound balls of clay and cover them.
  2. Start a timer and throw the best cylinder you can with the first ball. Aim for thin, even walls and not much clay in the bottom. Write down your time.
  3. Cut your time in half. Throw the second ball in that time.
  4. Cut it in half again. Throw the third ball in that time.
  5. Wire all three in half and compare them.

This one is great for those of us who get caught up in perfection. Working against the clock means you only do what's essential.

Day 2: Powering your pulls

Watch me pull up →

Goal: raise your walls in three pulls.

This rule changed my work when it was taught to me in 2007. Over time it helped me take weight out of the bottoms of my pots and showed me what a well-thrown pot should look and feel like.

  1. Wedge three 1-pound balls of clay and cover them.
  2. Center, open and raise the walls using only three pulls. No cheating!
  3. Take a photo, then wire the cylinder in half and look at the profile.
  4. Repeat with the other two and compare all three.

Tips for strong pulls

  • Slow the wheel to about half your centering speed.
  • Count down from 10 to 1 on each pull.
  • Put most of the pressure at the bottom, where the clay is thickest.
  • Set the lip after every pull.

Day 3: Throwing bigger

Goal: get comfortable with more clay on the wheel.

To throw bigger, you have to get used to bigger amounts of clay. The trick is to go up a little, then a lot, then settle in between. After the hardest one, the last one feels easier.

  1. Pick a weight that challenges you a little. For many people that's about 2.5 pounds.
  2. Wedge three balls: that weight, one pound more, and half a pound more. For example, 2.5, 3.5 and 3 pounds.
  3. Throw them in that order: small, biggest, middle.
  4. Cut each one open and compare the walls and bottoms.

Still getting comfortable with 1 pound? Use 1.5, 2.5 and 2 pounds instead.

Reading your cut cylinders

Wire each pot straight down the middle and look at the profile. Here's what it's telling you.

What you see Likely cause Try this
Thick bottom, thin top Not enough pressure at the start of each pull Put most of the pressure in the first inch
Bulge partway up the wall Pressure eased off too early or unevenly Keep a steady count and move up at a steady speed
Thick clay where wall meets floor Pull started above the bottom Start each pull right at the base, pressing in and down
Bottom thicker than 1/4 inch Opening stopped too high Check depth with your needle tool before opening
Walls slumping or twisting Too much water or time Sponge out water; three pulls and a faster throw

Repeat any day, any time

Cut open a pot every so often, even after the challenge, to check your progress. You'll be surprised how quickly your walls even out.

Keep going